Saturday, 14 December 2013

Outrage over Twitter’s blocking policy highlights a clash of values at the heart of the network

SUMMARY:
Twitter quickly reversed the changes it made to its blocking policy on Thursday, but the uproar it triggered highlights a tension at the core of the service: How do you ensure privacy on a network that is built to be public?

In case you missed all the sturm und drang on Thursday night, Twitter introduced — with no advance notice or warning — a new policy on what happens when a user blocks another user, a policy that significantly changed how that feature had functioned in the past. After an outpouring of criticism from victims of harassment, the company reversed the changes and restored the old policy. But the issue at the heart of this uproar isn’t likely to go away any time soon, because it’s baked into the way that Twitter works.
In a nutshell, Twitter is a hybrid of public and private: tweets are public by default, and the “asymmetric following” model that underpins the network means anyone can follow you whether you like it or not — something that is impossible with Facebook. Blocking was an attempt to bolt on privacy protections, but it has never really worked all that well, as even critics of the latest change will admit.
Being public is part of the company’s DNA, to the point where it fights for the free-speech rights of its users even when they say terrible things — as it did during a lawsuit over homophobic and anti-Semitic comments made by some users in France, where such activity is illegal. Some see this commitment as a positive thing (as I do), but it has a downside as well, and that emerges when harassment and abuse occur. Balancing those two competing forces is not an easy task.

An attempt to make blocking less obvious

It’s not clear how much advance planning or discussion with users went into the new blocking policy (I’ve asked Twitter for comment, and will update if and when I get some) and that seemed to be part of the problem many users had with it. It emerged fully-formed, with no consultation, to the point where some users compared it to the unilateral actions Twitter took against third-party developers.
According to CEO Dick Costolo and communications officer Jim Prosser, both on Twitter and in comments made to Forbes magazine, one of the main goals with the new policy was to make it more difficult for those who were blocked to know that they had been blocked. Under the old approach, users were notified of the block, and this often resulted in retaliatory behavior that increased the harassment or abuse — and Costolo suggested that some users who had been abused had specifically requested this change.
At the same time, however, the new policy changed the way that blocking affected the blocked user in some fairly significant ways — ways that many of those who have been subjected to harassment and abuse thought made the feature worse. For example, under the old policy a blocked user couldn’t interact with the tweets of the person who blocked them, either by retweeting or favoriting or adding them to lists, etc. All of these things became possible under the new policy, however.

No comments:

Post a Comment